BMV and BIVA issuers face the unique challenge of simultaneously complying with IFRS S2 (CNBV) and NIS B-1 (CINIF) for the same fiscal year, implying two regulatory frameworks, two regulators, and potentially two external assurance processes. Without a centralized platform, companies end up with sustainability and finance teams operating in silos, collecting redundant data in non-auditable spreadsheets. The overlap between IBSO indicators and IFRS S2 metrics is significant but not total, requiring precise mapping.
Mexican private holdings are the most complex NIS B-1 application case because CINIF has not yet issued consolidation guidance for groups with heterogeneous activities. The current interpretation is that each NIF-applying subsidiary must report its own 30 IBSO indicators — which can multiply compliance costs by 5-10x for a group with many subsidiaries.
CFO and Board of private holding required to consolidate NIS B-1 across 5+ subsidiaries with different business models
No CINIF methodology for NIS B-1 consolidation across subsidiaries in different sectors — no guidance on how to aggregate heterogeneous indicators (energy intensity of manufacturing + logistics?)
Each subsidiary has its own ERP (SAP, Oracle, Aspel, Excel) with no financial-ESG consolidation layer
Different fiscal year-ends across subsidiaries — some close in December, others in March or June, making uniform FY2025 consolidation impossible
Intragroup emissions double-counting — if the holding has an energy plant that sells electricity to its subsidiaries, who reports the Scope 1?
| Required KPI | Data Source | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| Group aggregate GHG Scope 1+2 (tCO2e — consolidated sum) | Purchased electricity (Scope 2) | High 🔴 |
| Total group energy consumption (GJ) | Electricity bills (Scope 2) | High 🔴 |
| Consolidated workplace incident rate per 200k hours (TIFR) | Meters and inventories | High 🔴 |
| Percentage of total group waste recycled or valorized (%) | HR / payroll system | Medium 🟡 |
| Women in management positions — aggregate across all subsidiaries (%) | ERP / accounting system | Medium 🟡 |
Unified energy consumption data with the same denominator when subsidiaries operate in different sectors (no single intensity KPI applies to manufacturing + distribution + services)
Inventory of subsidiaries that are NIF entities vs. those consolidating under international IFRS, to determine which fall within the NIS B-1 perimeter
Waste generated by type (hazardous, non-hazardous, special) aggregated across all subsidiaries with different NOM classifications
That is why manual Excel-based processes will not pass the 2027 assurance. Without automated traceability, an external auditor cannot verify the completeness or accuracy of emissions data.
Mapping and reconciliation of all 30 IBSO indicators with IFRS S2 metrics requirements to avoid duplication of effort
Unified GHG emissions data collection for Scope 1, 2, and 3 serving both frameworks simultaneously without double measurement
Management of two distinct assurance processes: CNBV's limited assurance under IFRS S2 and CINIF's review under NIS B-1, ideally with the same auditor
Alignment of reporting calendars — the integrated sustainability report must meet both deadlines from a single data collection cycle
Implementation of robust internal controls over sustainability information capable of supporting third-party assurance under both frameworks from 2027
Connect data sources (ERP, meters, suppliers) to a centralized platform
Review with internal audit team and adjust consolidation perimeter
Generate report in CNBV/CINIF format ready for external assurance
Eliminate spreadsheets in Holding Company. Climatta connects your systems and automatically collects Group aggregate GHG Scope 1+2 and other critical KPIs.
Every data point has source, date, and owner documented. The 2027 assurance auditor can trace every figure to its origin in your systems.
Generates the report in the exact CNBV + CINIF format — tables, metrics, and narrative. No last-minute manual reformatting.
Climatta connects to Holding Company systems in 4 weeks. No months-long IT project or external implementation consultant.
Climatta centralizes all data collection, generates the report in regulatory format, and leaves it ready for 2027 external assurance. No spreadsheets.