BMV and BIVA issuers face the unique challenge of simultaneously complying with IFRS S2 (CNBV) and NIS B-1 (CINIF) for the same fiscal year, implying two regulatory frameworks, two regulators, and potentially two external assurance processes. Without a centralized platform, companies end up with sustainability and finance teams operating in silos, collecting redundant data in non-auditable spreadsheets. The overlap between IBSO indicators and IFRS S2 metrics is significant but not total, requiring precise mapping.
Mexico's listed agribusiness sector faces the largest data gap between real and reported Scope 1 of all BMV sectors. Bachoco estimates that its methane emissions from enteric fermentation (Scope 1) could be 3-4x higher than what they report with IPCC Tier 1 factors — a significant restatement risk if the 2027 assurance auditor requires Tier 2.
CFO and Sustainability Director of BMV-listed agribusiness companies
Enteric fermentation in bovine/porcine/poultry livestock (CH4 — Scope 1) — Tier 2 calculation requires animal census by species, breed, and production system that few agribusinesses have systematized
N2O emissions from nitrogen fertilizer use (Scope 1) — enormous variation by soil type, climate, and fertilizer formulation, with IPCC emission factors that differ from Mexican context
Deforestation in agricultural supply chain (Scope 3 Cat 1 from land use change) — grain suppliers in high-deforestation areas (Chiapas, Tabasco) without geospatial traceability
Water use in agricultural irrigation (NIS B-1 water Cat 1) — mixed sources (over-exploited aquifers, dams, own wells) without volumetric measurement per plot in contracts with producers
| Required KPI | Data Source | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| GHG per tonne of processed product (tCO2e/t, including biogenic) | Direct combustion (Scope 1) | High 🔴 |
| Water use intensity per kg of animal protein or tonne of grain (m³/t) | ERP / operating systems | High 🔴 |
| Percentage of suppliers with certified sustainable agricultural practices (%) | Cat 1 - Granos y materias primas agrícolas compradas | High 🔴 |
| Percentage of organic waste used as biogas or compost (%) | HR / payroll system | Medium 🟡 |
| Feed conversion ratio (FCR) by species as proxy indicator of emissions efficiency | ERP / accounting system | Medium 🟡 |
Enteric fermentation and manure management emissions by livestock type disaggregated by production unit (Scope 1 Tier 2 requires data per pen/farm)
Water footprint of irrigation per supplier plot — most with individual CONAGUA water concessions without centralization
Historical land use change (10 years) on supplier plots for Scope 3 Cat 1 of agricultural raw materials (requires satellite analysis)
That is why manual Excel-based processes will not pass the 2027 assurance. Without automated traceability, an external auditor cannot verify the completeness or accuracy of emissions data.
Mapping and reconciliation of all 30 IBSO indicators with IFRS S2 metrics requirements to avoid duplication of effort
Unified GHG emissions data collection for Scope 1, 2, and 3 serving both frameworks simultaneously without double measurement
Management of two distinct assurance processes: CNBV's limited assurance under IFRS S2 and CINIF's review under NIS B-1, ideally with the same auditor
Alignment of reporting calendars — the integrated sustainability report must meet both deadlines from a single data collection cycle
Implementation of robust internal controls over sustainability information capable of supporting third-party assurance under both frameworks from 2027
Connect data sources (ERP, meters, suppliers) to a centralized platform
Review with internal audit team and adjust consolidation perimeter
Generate report in CNBV/CINIF format ready for external assurance
Eliminate spreadsheets in Agribusiness. Climatta connects your systems and automatically collects GHG per tonne of processed product and other critical KPIs.
Every data point has source, date, and owner documented. The 2027 assurance auditor can trace every figure to its origin in your systems.
Generates the report in the exact CNBV + CINIF format — tables, metrics, and narrative. No last-minute manual reformatting.
Climatta connects to Agribusiness systems in 4 weeks. No months-long IT project or external implementation consultant.
Climatta centralizes all data collection, generates the report in regulatory format, and leaves it ready for 2027 external assurance. No spreadsheets.